The Complete Motown Singles Collection Vol. 12a: 1972
While the next volume contained a lot more diversification into different styles and artists, and probably slightly more killer deep cuts, this is one that continues the socially aware/psychedelic soul trend of recent years, quite a bit of funk and also concentrates on the traditional soul side of Motown too.
I have to say, though, that I prefer the second volume of 1972 material to this one - there are more true classics, more quality deep cuts and, for some reason, an overall richer sound quality.
⭐ Star hits
💠Hidden gems
Disc One
The Four Tops - Simple Game/L.A. (My Town)
Simple Game was a big, deep, orchestrated and romantic ballad with a powerful Levi Stubbs lead vocal as well as vocal contributions from all the group. It is full of superb vocal harmonies but it is not my favourite of their singles, I find it a bit too bombastic and less catchy than many of their other hits. That brass backing is very evocative however. It's a bit of a grower, I have to admit.L.A. (My Town) finds the Detroit boys fervently singing the praises of new Motown headquarters location Los Angeles, claiming is as their town. That's Americans for you, they change loyalties with a re-location just as they do with their sports teams. That said, it is one of those evocative, sun-drenched "California soul" numbers that has a real early seventies atmosphere.
Jimmy Ruffin - Our Favourite Melody/You Gave Me Love
Our Favourite Melody has the now Motown veteran sounding like Smokey Robinson would on 1974's Just My Soul Responding. The "na-na-na" chorus is very Temptations-esque. Overall, it's a fine serving of soul and I'll enjoy Jimmy singing anything. The song and the one below actually dated from 1970's Groove Governor album.
You Gave Me Love was initially recorded by The Supremes for their 1969 Cream Of The Crop valedictory album. It sounds comfortable and soulful in Jimmy's most capable hands. I love pretty much everything he ever did and this excellent 'b' side is no different. It drips with soul. Backing vocals on this, incidentally, are supplied by The Originals.
The Marvelettes - A Breath Taking Guy/You're The One For Me Bobby ðŸ’
Also dating from 1970, this was the last single from The Marvelettes. Only Wanda Young Rogers remained from the original line-up, backed here by The Andantes. They all did a great job on A Breath Taking Guy, which was originally a single for The Supremes in 1963, during their long "no hit period". Here it carries an updated bassy oomph to it, making it a bit of a forgotten gem.
A killer deep bass-line enhances the 'b' side, You're The One For Me Bobby, which, despite its early sixties teen pop-ish title, is a solid, punchy soulster of a song. Wanda's voice is strong and expressive on this song. The song is a Smokey Robinson one and this would be The Marvelettes' last ever single release.
The Originals - I'm Someone Who Cares/Once I Have You (I Will Never Let You Go)
I have never been a huge fan of The Originals, to be honest. They were a typical vocal harmony group who specialised in big, overwrought ballads. I'm Someone Who Cares is very representative of their work. The vocal, by C.P. Spencer, is a strong one, however.
Once I Have You (I Will Never Let You Go) is even more in late-night ballad territory. It is backed by a full, solid bass-line, but, that apart, there are many better cuts out there, for me at least.
Blue Scepter - Out In The Night/Gypsy Eyes
Something Motown seriously dabbled in after their relocation were white rock groups. Blue Scepter were one of those and this is the first of several decidedly un-Motown-sounding numbers. It is a rock song, albeit a soulful, brassy one.
Gypsy Eyes is simply full-on riffy rock and wailing guitar soloing. Like all these diversifications, its presence here is an odd one.
The Undisputed Truth - What It Is?/California Soul ðŸ’
What It Is? is upbeat, lively and full to the brim with pulsating funky soul. Joe Harris, Brenda Joyce and Billie Calvin lay down some fantastic vocals here. The sound is also absolutely wonderful in its remastered format. Big, warm, full and bassy. I love it. Like many Truth songs, it was initially cut by The Temptations, appearing on their Solid Rock album from the same year.California Soul was a Nickolas Ashford-Valerie Simpson song, previously recorded by Marvin Gaye and Tammi Terrell, amongst others. Here it is given that harmonious, funky Undisputed Truth treatment. The song completely drips with early seventies West Coast hippy funky vibe and it is also relevant that Motown had relocated from Detroit to Los Angeles and anything in praise of California, such as this and the above-mentioned The Four Tops' L.A. (My Town) was de rigeur.
Posse - Feel Like Givin' Up/Take Somebody Like You
Posse were a five-man vocal group protegéd by Eddie Kendricks of the Temptations. They were very like them too, although without the same vocal range. Feel Like Givin' Up is an Originals-esque dramatic ballad that doesn't quite hit the mark for me.
I can say the same about Take Somebody Like You, to an extent, but it is way more hooky and far more lively than its 'a' side. The group's vocals are nicely in harmony and, as I said, the song has a catchiness. The problem with Posse, I guess, is that they were not the Temptations.
The Temptations - Take A Look Around/Smooth Sailing (From Now On)
Take A Look Around is a hard-hitting "think about the children" "message song". The Temptations had begun the trend for these sort of aware songs back in 1969. It begins with big, orchestrated brass and strings, before a harpsichord leads us into the infectious vocals from all group members. It is classic early seventies Temptations. Check out that deep bass-line too. Excellent. That said, it is not really catchy enough to be a big hit single. It has "album track" stamped all over it.Smooth Sailing (From Now On) is a jaunty and poppy mid-sixties-style Motown number. It is quite Smokey Robinson & The Miracles-like, and was a hark back to the pre-psychedelic soul yeas for The Temptations. It's a good one though, far more commercially appealing than its 'a' side.
The Devastating Affair - I Want To Be Humble/My Place
The Devastating Affair were best known as backing singers on many Diana Ross solo recordings. Here they released a couple of songs in their own right. I Want To Be Humble showcases their mixed male and female vocal harmonies well, but it isn't particularly special. As with many of these 1972 songs, though, its stereo version is much better than the mono one.
My Place is a groovy, vaguely funky little pop song. It has hints of Diana Ross & The Supremes' 1965-67 work, although the funky clavinet backing is very 1972.
Michael Jackson - Rockin' Robin/Love Is Here And Now You're Gone ⭐
Yes, Rockin' Robin is pure bubblegum, but I still love it. I guess it just takes me back to my childhood. I was twelve, Jackson was twelve. I thought both the song and the boy were great at the time. Listening to it now, it still resonates as being a really good pop song. For a twelve year-old boy, you have to say it is pretty damn impressive, however poppy. Love the bongo and drums backing too. Flap those wings now.....Diana Ross & The Supremes' Love Is Here And Now You're Gone gets a really confident treatment. It is very much the equal of the original and actually sounds quite a lot like it. Jackson's young voice sort of matches the original Diana Ross vocal.
Disc Two
Gladys Knight & The Pips - Can You Give Me Love With A Guarantee/If You're Gonna Leave (Just Leave) ⭐
Can You Give Me Love With A Guarantee was another fine, big-voiced ballad from the marvellous Gladys Knight. If it is classic, warm-voiced gospelly soul you are after, let Gladys serve you.
If You're Gonna Leave (Just Leave) isn't half bad either. Everything Gladys did was classy. The song was initially recorded in 1970 by the Originals. Give me Gladys's version all day long.
Frankie Valli - Love Isn't Here (Like It Used To Be)/Poor Fool
Sixties falsetto legend Frankie Valli (and The Four Seasons) signed to Motown at this point, which was somewhat surprising, I guess. This single was credited to Valli alone. Love Isn't Here (Like It Used To Be) has a huge rock guitar intro before it turns into a smoother ballad, featuring Valli's voice an octave or two lower than sometimes it had been. On the rousing chorus, however, he is unmistakable. As with some of this "new" Motown material, typically Motown it wasn't.
Poor Fool is a classic voice, piano and slow, melodious bass-backed ballad. Once more the drums kick in for a big Valli chorus. Look, these two are ok, but there are many more Valli tracks that I prefer.
Jr. Walker & The All-Stars - Walk In The Night/I Don’t Want To Do Wrong ⭐
Walk In The Night, a beautiful, catchy saxophone-driven (mainly) instrumental, was a huge hit, and deservedly so. Once again, it is a successful partnership of saxophone and backing singers. Great stuff. I have loved the track for years now, right back to 1976, when I first heard it on the Motown Gold vinyl compilation. For me it is one of the greatest instrumental hits of all time. The only vocals on it are a few "walk in the night, dah-dooby-dooby-dah" lines. It is one of the biggest hits on this collection.I Don’t Want To Do Wrong is a smoky, late night slice of sweet soul. The track, however, is basically an instrumental with layered backing vocals but somehow you don’t really notice. It works anyway. It didn't matter with the 'a' side and it doesn't matter here. A vocal version had been a hit the previous year for Gladys Knight.
Edwin Starr - Take Me Clear From Here/Ball Of Confusion
Big ol' bull elephant shouter Edwin Starr went full-on fuzzy psychedelic soul with the stomping Take Me Clear From Here, a very Temptations/Undisputed Truth-style song.
Talking of The Temptations, Edwin's cover of their socially-aware classic Ball Of Confusion isn't really the match of theirs, despite some great bass and psych-ish fuzzy guitar swirling all over it. Its sheer freakout trippiness takes something away from the song, for me. If I hadn't heard the Temptations' version, though, I think I'd love it.
G. C. Cameron - I'm Gonna Get You (Parts 1 & 2) ðŸ’
In a style somewhat similar to that of Edwin Starr we get ex-Spinner G. C. Cameron's excellent driving funker I'm Gonna Get You here. Spread across both sides of the 45 rpm single, it is a stream of consciousness ad hoc James Brown grunting serving of funk. Cameron just gets into his thang and keeps going as the brass wails and the fatback drums pound. This is possibly as deeply funky as Motown ever got.
Gladys Knight & The Pips - Help Me Make It Through The Night ⭐
A true 100% classic Motown ballad and arguably Gladys's greatest ever single/song (certainly for Motown). Everything about it is just beautiful. There's really not much more to say, is there? Soul Heaven. What a bass-line too. The song was written, incidentally, by Kris Kristofferson while sitting on an oil tower platform in South Louisiana. Of all the songs in this collection, this is probably the most "classic", and the one everybody knows. It is said that the crackling during the spoken intro was left on there because Gladys sung it in one take, a take that was just so damn good it had to be the one for release. It may be an apocryphal story, but I hope not, because I like it.The Sisters Love - Mr. Fix-It Man/You've Got To Make the Choice ðŸ’
The Sisters Love were not sisters, by the way. Mr. Fix-It is a fantastic piece of Memphis-style funky soul that sounds as if it is straight off the Stax label. Like all the girls' cuts, it is a mighty impressive one. It is one of those Motown songs that actually had a Southern soul sound to it. "If you can't fix it" - the sisters grittily sing - "maybe the milkman can". Interesting....
You've Got To Make The Choice is in the same kick-ass fatback style. Proper down 'n' dirty funky soul. As I said, there's something really Southern-sounding about these two songs.
R. Dean Taylor - Taos New Mexico/Shadow
White country-ish singer Taylor had hits with Indiana Wants Me, There's A Ghost In My House and Gotta See Jane. On Taos New Mexico he mines that Tex-Mex seam that Tony Christie did with Is The Way To Amarillo, the song full of Mariachi-style brass and a main girl character called Maria. It's about as un-Motown as you could possibly get, but it is incredibly singalong. I do like R. Dean Taylor.
The 'b' side, Shadow, sounds so 1968 to me. Lyrically, it's a bit dodgy, isn't it, with Taylor serenading a 14 year-old that has occupied his mind due to her having the "body of a woman". Oh dear. He wouldn't get away with that today, would he? Taylor often liked to inject a bit of "edge" into his lyrics. Again, it features some Mexican-influenced brass.
The Commodores - The Zoo (The Human Zoo)/I'm Looking For Love ðŸ’
Full-on funk here from the youthful (comparatively) Commodores, long before their classic sweet, smooth soul years. Lionel Richie is on keyboards here, as opposed to out front. Produced by Gloria Jones and Pam Swayer, The Zoo (The Human Zoo) is an early funk classic from the group. It also achieved popularity on the Northern Soul scene, despite its funky sound.
I'm Looking For Love has an I'm Coming Out (Diana Ross) guitar riff and a vague Latin feel to its intrinsic funkiness. It's got great percussion throughout as well. The Commodores would not have a hit, however, until 1974's instrumental groover Machine Gun.
Disc Three
Rare Earth - What'd I Say/Nice To Be With You
What'd I Say is indeed the Ray Charles song but, to. be totally honest, it sounds nothing like it. In places you get a riff or two that you recognise but it is pretty much like a Rare Earth original. Whatever, it is a seven minute plus rocking workout (the single version is, of course, shorter) that utilises both the group's instrumental prowess and their irrepressible energy. The jazzy bit about three minutes in is excellent. It rocks out big time.
Nice To Be With You is an acoustic and piano-backed ballad with no Motown feel to be found anywhere within earshot.
Eddie Kendricks - Let Me Run Into Your Lonely Heart/Eddie's Love
Let Me Run Into Your Lonely Heart is superbly funky, full of fatback drums, fine horns and guitar. Kendricks' vocal again proves his versatility. It is in the funky style of his later hits Keep On Truckin' and Boogie Down.
Eddie's Love is a fine, robust mid-paced number in a Temptations style that suffers a little from a somewhat grainy production and a slightly grating vocal from Eddie, surprisingly.
Thelma Houston - Me And Bobby McGee/No-One's Gonna Be A Fool Forever ðŸ’
Later to be disco singer Thelma (Don't Leave Me This Way) Houston channels her inner Janis Joplin on this delightfully gritty Motown rarity. Many people have no idea that she covered the song. I love it, she gives it the soulful, dirty delivery it demands.
Talking of great rarities, No-One's Gonna Be A Fool Forever is one of this collection's finest deep cuts. It's a great, bassy soul song with a killer chorus and Thelma shows just what a fine soul voice she has. Classic 1972 soul. It's amazing the little diamonds one can uncover on collections such as this.
G.C. Cameron - What It Is, What It Is/You Are The Special One ðŸ’
What It Is, What It Is (not to be confused with The Undisputed Truth song, What It Is?) is a mix of soul and funk-pop. Cameron's strong and soulful voice is augmented by some high-pitched female backing vocals (from Syreeta Wright, no less) and the song has a muscular brassy, bass sound. Nice one. Cameron certainly put out some seriously underrated material.
You Are The Special One is more similarly industrial strength soul with a nice funky wah-wah, drum and vocal break in the middle. Top quality again.
The Jackson 5 - Little Bitty Pretty One/If I Have To Move A Mountain
If I Have To Move A Mountain finds Michael still in high voice mode on a syrupy but appealing ballad. I would put money that it was a track that dated from earlier sessions. I'm right too - it had been intended for an earlier album than The Lookin' Through The Windows one it ended up on.
The Supremes - Automatically Sunshine/Precious Little Things ⭐
Automatically Sunshine, a Smokey Robinson song, has Jean Terrell and Mary Wilson sharing vocals once more on the well-known and irresistibly appealing hit single. It is one of those I loved at the time of release and still do. Lord above, The Supremes put out some great singles from 1970-72. I love that intro and those smoky vocals.Precious Little Things, the 'b' side, is a shuffling, rhythmic groove of a love song, featuring some jazzy and mighty attractive guitar from co-writer Marv Tarplin, of Smokey's Miracles, of course. It is a relaxing as a nice warm, bubbly bath. Check out that groovy piano bit near the end too. Many Motown records were full of little surprises like that.
The Courtship - It's The Same Old Love/Last Row, First Balcony
It's The Same Old Love is a sweet, lush and smooth love song, sung by Billy (What Is Black?) Proctor (see 12b). It was also recorded by the Jerry Ross Symposium (also see 12b). It has a lovely saxophone solo in the middle. It almost sounds like an early sixties Beatles song in its cadences at times. Something about the vocals and the lyrics.
Last Row, First Balcony is equally saccharine, albeit classily delivered. It is very Stylistics/Delfonics-ish. Nice harmonies but pretty insipid all the same. It is one of those that grows on me, however.
Xit - Nihaa Shil Hozho (I Am Happy About You)/End?
A total oddity here. Xit were a New Mexico group comprising Native Americans. This was a most unusual step for Motown to take. Nihaa Shil Hozho (I Am Happy About You) is an attractive folky slow-paced number sung partly in Navajo. It is totally uncommercial. An album track if ever I heard one. The group were trying to emulate Redbone, a Native American group who had achieved some contemporary success. Their album was called Plight Of The Redman and they dressed in buckskin for the cover's sepia photo. It looked as if it was taken in 1870.
End? has some typically Native American drums and vocals. Its vocal is a spoken diatribe concerning the treatment of the Native American. The group were unfortunately perceived as militant and they faded away. One of their members, Tom Bee, contributed the Native American chant that so enhanced Smokey Robinson's 1974 single Just My Soul Responding, however.
The Four Tops - I Can't Can't Quit Your Love/Happy (Is A Bumpy Road) ðŸ’
I Can't Quit Your Love is a great deep cut from The Four Tops. It combines a contemporary muscular funk sound with a catchy chorus and a typically strong Levi Stubbs vocal. Wah-wah guitars dominate the song's excellent sound. It was the group's lowest chart placing to date, which was a shame, because it was a good one. The track was also recorded by Bobby Taylor in 1973 and The Jackson 5, who included it on their Skywriter album from the same year.
Happy (Is A Bumpy Road) had been recorded by The Supremes in 1971 and, despite The Four Tops making a solid, muscular fist of it, it is the girls' one that I much prefer.
Vincent DiMirco - I Can Make It Alone/Come Clean
I know nothing much about Vincent DiMirco other than this was his only single for Motown. The 'a' side is a pleasant, well-produced late night ballad while the 'b' side, Come Clean, is most unusual - a stripped back, bluesy acoustic guitar and voice lament. It is one of Motown's most unique cuts. DiMirco wrote The Supremes' Up The Ladder To The Roof with Frank Wilson and also wrote songs for The Originals, Edwin Starr, The Four Tops and David Ruffin.
Disc Four
Stevie Wonder - Superwoman/I Love Every Little thing About You ⭐
Eric & The Vikings - It's Too Much For Man To Take Too Long/Time Don't Wait
Eric & The Vikings sound like a rock group, don't they? Well, they were a Detroit soul outfit and It's Too Much For Man To Take Too Long is actually a sumptuous Stylistics-ish ballad with a hard edge, a fine vocal and a hint of The O'Jays about it. It is a quality song and a real soul deep cut.
Time Don't Wait, a killer of a funkster, is also more than acceptable. Check out the wah-wah, the pounding beat and some excellent vocals. Why did some of these groups make it and others not, I wonder? Maybe there was just so much great soul around that the ones who fell by the wayside didn't really deserve to?
Howl The Good - Long Way From Home/Why Do You Cry
Long Way From Home is a soulful, gospelly ballad from this folk/rock group with a strange name, based, bizarrely on the name of a 10th century Welsh king named Hywel (phonetically pronounced Howl). It's a solid number with an impressive guitar solo in the middle. I quite like it, I have to say.
Why Do You Cry is a funky little gem of a Doobie Brothers/Marshall Tucker Band-sounding rocker. Motown it sure isn't, but it is a robust piece of early seventies fare. It's country rock, though, isn't it?