Mary Chapin Carpenter: The Dirt And The Stars - 2020
My beloved Mary Chapin Carpenter is back, like an old friend you haven’t seen for a few years. We meet up and talk for hours, at times getting emotional, but at all times serious, affectionate and sincere. Listening to her albums is like that. The sister I never had.
Farther Along And Further In reminds us just what a song-writing craftswoman Mary Chapin Carpenter is, its slow, melodic, insistent beat in perfect time with her always wise words and expressive, comforting voice. Mary doesn’t really do throwaway songs, not these days anyway, everything has a serious, heartfelt, thoughtful meaning. This is certainly one of those.
A delightful piano, guitar and drum intro welcomes in the once more reassuring words of It’s Ok To Be Sad. Mary is in her sixties now, like me, and she knows how to tell it like it is even more than she ever did. All Broken Hearts Break Differently is also a typically gentle but moving MCC song. When I hear things like this all is ok in my world, despite the sadness in the song. Her voice soothes me.
Mary loves a bit of tender nostalgia and she brings it out for us in the beautiful, reflective Old D-35 (a guitar) “twilight in the fall and the sound of your old D-35”. Lovely. Voice, guitar and piano combine perfectly here.Mary has become increasingly cynical about US politics in recent years (unsurprisingly) and she expresses that here on the Mark Knopfler-esque American Stooge. I’m not sure who the corrupt politician is she is referring to, but it could be any of them, to be honest. Either way, it’s a great song, powerful and pulling no punches. It is also here that the album gets a bit grittier, albeit briefly.
Where The Beauty Is returns us to warm sensitivity, as indeed does the tender Nocturne. You know, I can honestly say that Mary has never written a bad song. Time for a bit of typical Mary riffy rock on Secret Keepers, a fine song notable also for being the cause of Mary’s first “parental advisory” sticker for her “you fucked it up” line. Nice guitar solo in it too.
The album ends with two quiet numbers in Asking For A Friend and Everybody’s Got Something before a classic piece of MCC guitar rock nostalgia in Between The Dirt And The Stars (about listening to The Rolling Stones’ Wild Horses). Nobody does this sort of thing better than our Mary.